Equity is not equality: why the same thing for everyone is not fair
5 min read
The objection comes up in every classroom, every family and every workplace: why would one person get something the others don't? Because equality treats people identically, and equity gives each person what they need to reach the same place.
Same thing for everyone leaves some behind
Handing out identical tools assumes identical starting points. A written instruction given once helps a child who processes speech easily and loses one whose working memory is already full. Nothing about the instruction changed — the wall did not move — only the height of the person facing it.
An accommodation is a stepladder, not an advantage
Extra time, a written copy of the lesson, noise-reducing headphones: none of these make the task easier. They remove an obstacle that had nothing to do with the skill being assessed. Measuring someone's maths while they fight to stay in a noisy room measures the noise, not the maths.
How to explain it without a debate
Two sentences usually settle it. Glasses are not an advantage over people who see clearly. And any accommodation that helps only one person is often worth offering to everyone: a visible timer, a written instruction on the board or a partially pre-filled worksheet costs nothing and singles nobody out.
Frequently asked questions
- Isn't an accommodation unfair to the other children?
- No. An accommodation removes an obstacle unrelated to the skill being assessed. It does not lower the requirement, it makes the requirement reachable.
- How do I explain equity to a child?
- Compare it to shoes: everyone gets shoes that fit, not everyone gets the same size. Same need met, different means.
Informational content. It is neither a diagnosis nor medical advice and does not replace professional care.
Full site in French